Cub Cadet versus John Deere Comparison

cub cadet vs john deere picture

In this cub cadet versus john deere review, we will be talking about specifications of these amazing riding lawn mowers and try to help you decide which one is suitable for your own purposes.


We will choose the best-valued and quality riding lawn mowers from both of these brands and compare them in order to help you decide which one you should buy.  

More about both of these brands

Cub Cadet

Cub Cadet is an American company which produces mostly outdoor power equipment- including riding lawn mowers. These products are distributed worldwide, through independent retail dealers. 

Since 1960, Cub Cadet started their production in Kentucky.

The first model ever made was the International Cub Cadet tractor, better known as the Original. It had 7 horsepower, round fenders, headlights, and a creeper gear. 

Now, Cub Cadet is one of the biggest manufacturers out there. For the purpose of this review, we will take Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series model and compare it with John Deere’s finest. 

xt1 model

John Deere

John Deere is a brand name of Deere and Company. This American manufacturer is listed as 105th in the Fortune 500 and 407th when it comes to a global ranking. It is one of the biggest manufacturers when it comes to riding lawn mowers. 

With an experience of more than 180 years, John Deere produces top-notch lawn mowers today. This company employs more than 67.000 people. 

Anyhow, when it comes to this brand, we will take John Deere E130 as the representative of John Deere brand and compare it with a similar quality model of Cub Cadet.


Now, one of the greatest questions in the riding lawn mower world is who will win in john deere vs cub cadet. They both are well-known manufacturers all over the world, with a long history of making riding lawn mowers. 

We will be discussing some general things of these two manufacturers as well as specific about Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series and John Deere E130, and in relation to that, claim the winner. 

e130 model

Cub Cadet Vs John Deere

Cutting performance

Now, when it comes to a cutting performance, both of these brands have passed our bagging tests. They showed incredible performance while cutting in side-discharge power mode. So, in relation to that, we have a tie situation.

Anyhow, there is a small difference considering the mulching test. On that field, Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series has a minor advantage. Moreover, the Cub Cadet is mulching grass clippings and making them fine, small fragments. That way fragments recede and nourish the earth. Never the less, the John Deere E130 mulches with incredible level and it surely won’t disappoint. 

Considering overall performance, we may declare the winner of this round. With a small advantage on a mulching matter, this round belongs to Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series.

Handling, controls, and comfort

One of the biggest mistakes that you might make is not putting a comfort of the riding lawn mower on top of your priorities. There are some regions, where the grass grows unbelievably fast. In those regions, you might spend over 40 hours during one season on a land mower. Is there anything worse than spending 40 hours driving uncomfortable mower?

With both of these brands, you will get plush and super comfy high-back mower seat. There are some amazing features that both brands offer, such as washout ports in charge of easier cleaning under that, sometimes unreachable, cutting deck. Also, they have an automatic drive system. 

Now, there is a small difference when it comes to turning, steering, braking, and stability. That difference goes in a favor of the John Deer E130 due to a slightly better and refined ride. 

So, the winner of this round between Cub Cadet vs John Deere is John Deer E130.

Price, value, maintenance, and reliability

Considering the complexity of these riding lawn mowers, you will need to maintain them and sometimes repair. Now, maintenance isn’t that much expensive, but repair can cause a headache. Therefore, considering that matter, a research has shown that John Deer is a brand with a small percentage of breaking.  

Therefore, only 21 percent of their products are breaking by the 4th year, compared with 36 percent of Cub Cadet. This is a big difference. Repairing can cost a lot sometimes, and avoiding these unnecessary costs can sometimes be relieving. 

Now, when it comes to the price of these riding lawn mowers, John Deere is slightly more expensive than the Cub Cadet. In general, if we abstract similar quality products from these two brands, we can conclude that John Deer is about 10% more expensive than the Cub Cadet. 

If we connect the dots between a price and reliability (maintenance and repairing), we will get a tie situation. John Deer is a bit more expensive, but on the other hand, statistically speaking, it breaks rarely.

Given everything that we previously said about these two, we may conclude that this round is drawn. John Deer wins for reliability while Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series prevails in cost matter. 


In the light of everything that we previously said in this cub cadet vs john deere 2018 short review, we may conclude that both brands produce top-notch lawn mowers. 

As we said, in the matter of cutting performance, both Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series and John Deere E130 are equally good. When it comes to mulching, Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series mulches a bit better than John Deere E130.

Secondly, there are some amazing features that both brands offer- automatic drive system and washout ports. 

In the matter of comfort, both, Cub Cadet XT1 Enduro Series and John Deere E130 excel. They offer comfy and plush high-back seat.


Finally, statistically speaking, John Deer shows a bit better reliability than Cub Cadet. Only 22 percent of their models are estimated to break by the fourth year, compared with 37 percent of Cub Cadet. 

All in all, we hope that you will find this cub cadet versus john deere review useful in deciding which one you should get for yourself.

your best bet

man riding lawn tractor cutting grass

Get yourself one of our recommended products for 2018

We reviewed top quality riding lawn mowers in this article. You will definitely find something for yourself!

Riding Lawn Mower Reviews HQ is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of, Inc. or its affiliates.